Samantha Brennan reviews The Bee and the Orange Tree

20120804-110811[1]Why I had to pick it up

That blurb!

Okay, let me go back a little…

Right now, I’m wrists-deep in metaphorical ink, writing and plotting my middle-grade fantasy series Stella Duke and the Sandgirl’s Curse. The history and politics of the magical world I’m painstakingly building have their beginnings in French author Charles Perrault’s 1697 version of Cinderella, the first iteration of the tale to feature a fairy godmother. I tell you this fun fact to explain why this period in literary history—the time of the first fairy tales—was pinging on my authorial radar.

Enter: The Bee and the Orange Tree and that blurb!

Promising to reveal the life of Marie Catherine d’Aulnoy, the seventeenth-century author who invented what would become modern-day fairy tales, the back cover appealed to my professional curiosity as well as my penchant for any story that puts strong women front and centre. I just had to know more about this time in our literary history as well as the impressive, mysterious woman who created a genre.

Why I couldn’t put it down

Melissa Ashley nails the monumental task of creating a piece of historical fiction that embodies the character and personality of an era while also engaging the contemporary reader. She does it with well-defined language, spellbinding imagery and super-tight dialogue; Melissa herself says it’s a balance that required multiple drafts to get right.

Not only did I enjoy the foray into the seventeenth-century literary circles, where fierce creative women—otherwise oppressed by government, church and men—came together to support each other through story and social convention, but I was captivated by the lives of the story’s three main characters. I couldn’t get enough of the insights into literary salons and old-world publishing, and I couldn’t look away from these characters until their destinies were finally revealed.

Why writers will want to read it

The Bee and the Orange Tree is a beautiful book with a strong, distinctive voice, making it a must-read novel for writers of all fiction, historical or otherwise. Falling in love with this book was a dual experience for me. As a reader, I was consumed by the world-building—the characters, the plot, the tension… As a writer, I was struck over and over again by the voice, the art and the stamina. More than once, lost in the story-telling, I stopped short at a particular paragraph or turn of phrase and had to read it twice or more again, just to marvel at the craftsmanship. And Melissa does not drop the ball once—the writing is solid and striking until the very last page.

Reposted from

One thought on “Samantha Brennan reviews The Bee and the Orange Tree

  1. The Birdman’s Wife is her first novel and it is wonderful too. Again about a strong woman who supported her husband to the detriment of herself and her family. Beautifully told, the images that it provoked were very detailed. Look forward to much more of Melissa work.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s